The topic for blog
#7 was select out of the four
stories from the gold coast
section the one that you feel is the best example of noir and one that
would be the most difficult to classify as noir.
So now let me
start with the fact that
all four stories sucked, they
are very short stories
so they don’t really have any context they don’t
get
you wrapped up and
make you want to keep
reading it’s like four very shorts stories that
are meant to torture the mind of the reader with
doubts, so at the end
of the every single
story you are intrigued
on the why,
the how of
the stories and you end up
with this confused look
on your face that
just says really? That’s all you got?. But anyhow.
Let me start
with the one I believe is the one that it’s hardest to classify as a
noir.
“Kinship.” By Brian Ascalon Roley. (299).
In my personal opinion this story was the hardest one to classify as noir, it does not seem dark at all it does not present that noir ambiance, it just feels like a story being told by someone who wants to get it out of t heir system. It lacks the femme fatale, and the protagonist could pass as a so call detective but not in the true sense of the word because all he investigates is the house where the person that hurt veronica’s husband lives. And the only sentence that I can perceive as dark and that it gives me that sensation of noir its all the way at the end of the story.
“Kinship.” By Brian Ascalon Roley. (299).
In my personal opinion this story was the hardest one to classify as noir, it does not seem dark at all it does not present that noir ambiance, it just feels like a story being told by someone who wants to get it out of t heir system. It lacks the femme fatale, and the protagonist could pass as a so call detective but not in the true sense of the word because all he investigates is the house where the person that hurt veronica’s husband lives. And the only sentence that I can perceive as dark and that it gives me that sensation of noir its all the way at the end of the story.
I am a father too, I
said it
loud enough for Manny to hear, and
then I reached down
and stuck him.(317)
That is the only moment when you can truly feel the noir because you can just picture yourself as the victim, and feel Tomas heavy breathing full of anger tell you that last words you will ever hear.
That is the only moment when you can truly feel the noir because you can just picture yourself as the victim, and feel Tomas heavy breathing full of anger tell you that last words you will ever hear.
But that is about
it there is no other
moment when you feel
the chills of noir,
the sensation that you are trapped and there will no way
out.
Now the one
that can best
represent what Noir is.
Even though all four
stories where totally lame the
one that can pass
as noir because to be honest
is not the best example
but it will be out
these four stories I would
say it has to be “The girl who kissed Barnaby Jone” By Scott
Phillips. I personally thought the story
sucked but it does
have more characteristics of what noir
is classified to be, it includes
the protagonist that’s between a
fine line of good and evil,
you have the Femme fatale
that drags him to his
own damnation, also he know he is a
sucker for her he acknowledges the fact that he
would do anything
for that female.
“I have a great big boner
with Cherie’s name on it, and if she asked me to shovel shit I’d ask her how
fast she needed it shoveled. “Where, exactly?”(287)
The female known
as Cherie’s is
the Femme fatale, she is the expert in getting men to
do what she wants, well kind of because in this story, the one man
she calls decides to ditch
her because he realizes she is
bat shit crazy. At the end
he still ends death or
that’s what the
end implies. All throughout this
ten page story she can
feel a little bit of
Noir it is all set up in a
dark environment you
have the lust factor the lust
and sex is
in most of the lines,
you have the protagonist who
falls like a dumbass for the
girl just because
she has a “smoking hot body”, you have a murder taken place
in shady place.
so therefore I believe that story
fits noir the best.
I noticed a lot of people chose to do this options, looks like you wrote more then usual nice work on your paragraph structure, each one had a good topic focus and I was able to find them. I think the story you selected had a good description of Neo-Noir, or of what neo-noir is suppose to describe. As always good work Sonia.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the insight, this time i didn't focus on how much words i needed, instead i focused on what i had to write and that was the outcome. :)
DeleteI like how you weren't afraid to admit that all four stories were rather boring. However I like how instead of beginning with the story that associates more with neo-noir you started off with the least likely. You not only explain the reasons why but you also gave examples from the story. Very good job on your blog.
ReplyDeleteI couldn't just keep it in i was falling a sleep while reading them even though they are short it took me a couple hours to read them all because i was getting distracted with the slightest most simple dumb things surrounding me and thank you.
DeleteGood post. I was going to choose "Kinship" as well for the one being least associated with noir but then I got into thinking about it. The protagonist, Tomas is in a way struggling between good and bad. Somewhere in the story when he's rushing out of the house his mom reminds him that he's on probation, "Tomas, you said you wouldn't! she said. You're on probation. You said you were finished with that life" (302). This isn't really much on why it would be noir but it's the reason why I decided not to chose it.
ReplyDelete